William Becker, The Climate Policy Expert's Blog


Climate Policy Expert

“Why Regulations Can Be Good”

06 Dec 16 | 13 comments

Why Regulations Can Be Good

Added 06 Dec 16 by the Climate Policy Expert | 13 comments

Bookmark and Share

Republican leaders in Congress and conservative think tanks are drawing up their lists of federal regulations they want President Trump to help them kill once he takes office. Judging by his campaign platform Trump is eager to cooperate. He has promised to “reform the entire regulatory code” and to issue a moratorium on new government rules that are not required by law.

Trump believes that government regulations “force jobs out of our communities” and punish Americans for doing business in the United States. “We will no longer regulate our companies and our jobs out of existence,” he has said.

Are there unnecessary or unnecessarily burdensome regulations? Undoubtedly. Do we want government controlling our lives? No. But some regulations are necessary to save our lives. Many actually create jobs, are wanted by business, advance important national goals and are necessary to protect the American people from the bad actors in our society.

The benefits of good government rules have been obvious for generations. Without laws like the Clean Air Act of 1970 and the Clean Water Act two years later, and without the regulations that implemented them, we would have a much dirtier and sicker country. Rivers would still be catching fire, more oil spills would be killing oceans, fish would be inedible because of toxins in their flesh, many more of our children would get sick or die from asthma caused by air pollution, cancer would be as common as the common cold, our water would be unsafe to drink and every day would be a bad-air day.

Before President Trump begins killing regulations (almost as complicated as creating them), he should weigh their benefits and costs case by case. Here are a few things he should consider specifically in regard to regulations on business and industry, the most common source of complaints that the government handcuffs job creation.

First, to put things in context, there are more than 22.6 million businesses in the United States. Nearly three of every four are small enterprises, the biggest source of new jobs but also the firms that because of limited resources may have the hardest time complying with government rules. Depending on the nature of their enterprises, they must deal with rules that range from worker safety to the quality of our food. It’s fair to say that relatively few companies are knowingly engaged in practices that hurt people or the environment.

But not all companies are good corporate citizens. Many regulations, including most of those involving environmental protection, are a result of industries failing to regulate themselves.

Industries could monitor their “own adherence to legal, ethical, or safety standards, rather than have an outside, independent agency such as a third-party entity monitor and enforce those standards.” But history is filled with examples of corporations that put social responsibility far down their priority lists, if it is on their lists at all. Their first priorities of course are profit, shareholder returns and competitive advantage. But in pursuit of those goals, some companies engage in practices that are socially irresponsible, if not dangerous.

Prominent examples today are the powerful companies that produce and burn fossil fuels. We now know that the pollution from fossil fuel combustion has saturated the atmosphere to the point that the Earth’s climate is changing in seriously dangerous ways. Oil and gas companies could be making the transition away from fossil fuels to clean energy not only to limit climate change, but also to become leaders in the rapidly growing clean energy sector. Instead and in general, the oil and gas industry is sticking to its old business model of pulling as much product out of the ground as possible. While the companies profit, millions of Americans already are being hurt by climate change and countless generations to come will continue to bear the cost of drought, fire, floods and other disasters.

In a perfect society, companies, like doctors, would commit to doing no harm. Their business model would be to profit from activities that are consistent with the public good. There are many companies that adhere to a kind of corporate hypocratic oath. More than 200 corporate CEOs representing 19 million employees worldwide are members of the World Council on Sustainable Development, for example. One of their projects is to have businesses use fuels that contain 50% less carbon, a strategy to grow the global market for clean and sustainable energy. More than 80 U.S. companies, including many of our largest, have promised to switch to 100% renewable energy.

Smart corporate leaders actually welcome reasonable regulation, although they may not admit it in public. Regulations ensure that each company and its competitors operate on the proverbial level playing field. Otherwise, clean companies that pay for pollution prevention would not be able to compete with dirty companies that don’t.

Regulations prevent bad actors from damaging the reputation of their industries and jeopardizing their “social license to operate”. Several of the regulations that reportedly are on the chopping block are focused on the natural gas industry, a sector whose production is booming at the same time some of its practices - fracking and methane leaks for example - are controversial. The Center for the New Energy Economy (CNEE) at Colorado State University has held annual conferences with leaders of the oil and gas industry to discuss issues like these. CNEE reports that:

Reasonable and effective regulation is important to natural gas producers because it creates business planning certainty; screens out the “bad actors”; reduces the chances that companies within the energy sector will obtain unfair advantage by engaging in irresponsible practices; and strengthens the industry’s “social license to operate” - i.e., public trust that energy is being produced in ways that are consistent with public health, welfare and quality of life.

The National Petroleum Council (NPC) concurs:

Achieving the economic, environmental and energy security benefits of North American natural gas and oil supplies requires responsible approaches to resource production and delivery...(I)n all locales and conditions, the critical path to sustained and expanded resource development in North America includes effective regulation and a commitment of industry and regulators to continuous improvement in practices to eliminate or minimize environmental risk.

Second, federal regulations are not created by fiat. There is no secret back room in which federal control freaks plot to regulate business. Most rules are the result of laws passed by the people’s representatives in Congress. Each proposed new rule must go through an arduous process of public and legal review before it can become final. Proposed rules are scrutinized for their costs and benefits to the American people. Once they are finalized, they are routinely challenged by lawsuits that further test their legality.

Third, regulations can create jobs. For example, federal rules that require companies to repair environmental damage have resulted in a “restoration industry” in the United States. Researchers at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill have determined that these rules support more than 220,000 jobs and $25 billion in economic activity. This restoration economy provides more direct jobs today than coal mining, logging or steel production.

Finally, most Americans support environmental regulation. The Pew Research Center reported earlier this year that while opinions vary from state to state, 59% of American adults nationwide say that stricter environmental regulations are worth the cost.

That’s not to say that conservatives and progressive all agree. Weeks before the election, Pew found a deep divide between Trump and Clinton supporters when it came to regulating carbon pollution.

But perhaps the divide is a result of the bad rap that government regulations routinely receive and often do not deserve. It would be a wonderful world if every American and every American company operated by the “do no harm” principle. Unfortunately, that is not the world we live in.

This article originally appeared at http://www.huffingtonpost.com/william-s-becker/why-regulations-can-be-go_b_13351686.html


William Becker

Climate Policy Expert

Serves as the Exec. Director of the Presidential Climate Action Project (PCAP). Served as Senior official at the U.S. Department of Energy (15 years)

view full biography >

View all of William Becker's blog entries >


There's a total of 13 comments for this blog entry. Have your say and add your own comment here.


<a href="http://www.iot-europoort.com/free-delivery/adidas-superstar-80s-stockholm-chic">adidas superstar 80s stockholm chic</a><a href="http://www.iot-europoort.com/free-shipping/cheap-nike-air-max-95-ultra-se-blue-black-trainers-sale-uk">cheap nike air max 95 ultra se blue black trainers sale uk</a><a href="http://www.iot-europoort.com/hot-sale/purple-and-yellow-nike-football-cleats">purple and yellow nike football cleats</a><a href="http://www.iot-europoort.com/just-release/nike-zoom-kobe-iv-4-basketball-shoes-asg-all-star-red">nike zoom kobe iv 4 basketball shoes asg all star red</a> <a href="http://www.thebeautyaudit.com/factory-price/nike-air-trainer-1-infrared-2" >nike air trainer 1 infrared 2</a> [url=http://www.thebeautyaudit.com/factory-price/nike-air-trainer-1-infrared-2]nike air trainer 1 infrared 2[/url]

26 Sep 2018 - 21:33 BST


<a href="http://www.4abcpodiatry.com/authentic/sale-mens-womens-nike-air-max-90-pinnacle-triple-black">sale mens womens nike air max 90 pinnacle triple black</a><a href="http://www.4abcpodiatry.com/best-seller/nike-air-vapormax-20-dusty-cactus">nike air vapormax 20 dusty cactus</a><a href="http://www.4abcpodiatry.com/big-sale/2013-nike-running-shoes-air-max-green-black-fluorescent-kids">2013 nike running shoes air max green black fluorescent kids</a><a href="http://www.4abcpodiatry.com/black-friday/air-max-97-2017-white">air max 97 2017 white</a> <a href="http://www.shawelydubos.com/outlet-online/nike-air-max-light-premium-qs-mita-keiji" >nike air max light premium qs mita keiji</a> [url=http://www.shawelydubos.com/outlet-online/nike-air-max-light-premium-qs-mita-keiji]nike air max light premium qs mita keiji[/url]

05 Oct 2018 - 18:35 BST


<a href="http://www.plasticsurgeonelpaso.com/2019_release/nike-air-penny-ii-college-blue-gs">nike air penny ii college blue gs</a><a href="http://www.plasticsurgeonelpaso.com/available_now/mens-nike-air-max-2017.5-black-orange-sweden">mens nike air max 2017.5 black orange sweden</a><a href="http://www.plasticsurgeonelpaso.com/a_first_look/nike-air-huarache-nike-air-huarache-1-nike-air-huarache-818597-500">nike air huarache nike air huarache 1 nike air huarache 818597 500</a><a href="http://www.plasticsurgeonelpaso.com/black_friday_sale/nike-air-zoom-hyperace-white-black-black-nike-volleyball-shoes-womens">nike air zoom hyperace white black black nike volleyball shoes womens</a> <a href="http://www.doncaster-wedding-photography.com/Upcoming-Sneakers/rukus-x-nike-sb-dunk-low-prm-crawfish" >rukus x nike sb dunk low prm crawfish</a> [url=http://www.doncaster-wedding-photography.com/Upcoming-Sneakers/rukus-x-nike-sb-dunk-low-prm-crawfish]rukus x nike sb dunk low prm crawfish[/url]

18 Oct 2018 - 20:38 BST


<a href="http://www.lovepopgirl.com/cheap/nike-kd-10-outlet-blinders-blac-blue-yellow-white">nike kd 10 outlet blinders blac blue yellow white</a><a href="http://www.lovepopgirl.com/clearance-sale/adidas-predator-18-2-fgag">adidas predator 18 2 fgag</a><a href="http://www.lovepopgirl.com/clearance/nike-air-maestro-2-ltd-white-hyper-jade">nike air maestro 2 ltd white hyper jade</a><a href="http://www.lovepopgirl.com/cyber-monday/2017-new-nike-kobe-ad-sneakers-for-men-low-golden-purple-black">2017 new nike kobe ad sneakers for men low golden purple black</a> <a href="http://www.hamiltonchampion.com/online-sale/nike-mens-white-black-lebron-soldier-10-colorful" >nike mens white black lebron soldier 10 colorful</a> [url=http://www.hamiltonchampion.com/online-sale/nike-mens-white-black-lebron-soldier-10-colorful]nike mens white black lebron soldier 10 colorful[/url]

21 Oct 2018 - 06:55 BST


<a href="http://www.bransonskillz.com/online_kicks/for-women-new-balance-leather-green-nb-wh574wgg-middle-cut-boots">for women new balance leather green nb wh574wgg middle cut boots</a><a href="http://www.bransonskillz.com/outlet/release-date-bodega-x-reebok-ventilator-terry-blay">release date bodega x reebok ventilator terry blay</a><a href="http://www.bransonskillz.com/popular-releases/mens-jordan-rising-high-black-wolf-grey-infrared-23-white">mens jordan rising high black wolf grey infrared 23 white</a><a href="http://www.bransonskillz.com/recommended/nike-air-zoom-pegasus-34-sequoia-dark-stucco-volt-black-880555-302">nike air zoom pegasus 34 sequoia dark stucco volt black 880555 302</a> <a href="http://www.meilleur-rachat-credit.com/online_kicks/nike-air-max-1-qs-gs-air-max-day-555766-147-white-sport-royal-neutral-grey" >nike air max 1 qs gs air max day 555766 147 white sport royal neutral grey</a> [url=http://www.meilleur-rachat-credit.com/online_kicks/nike-air-max-1-qs-gs-air-max-day-555766-147-white-sport-royal-neutral-grey]nike air max 1 qs gs air max day 555766 147 white sport royal neutral grey[/url]

22 Oct 2018 - 17:55 BST


<a href="http://www.barrietreeservice.com/replica/nike-kids-cleats-baseball">nike kids cleats baseball</a><a href="http://www.barrietreeservice.com/retro/nike-flyknit-air-max-black-water-blue-green">nike flyknit air max black water blue green</a><a href="http://www.barrietreeservice.com/the-cheapest/women-nike-air-max-2014-flyknit-black-red-blue">women nike air max 2014 flyknit black red blue</a><a href="http://www.barrietreeservice.com/wholesale/nike-air-max-97-ultra-17-womens-shoe-white-wolf-grey-black">nike air max 97 ultra 17 womens shoe white wolf grey black</a> <a href="http://www.spiritedveg.com/brand-new/nike-air-max-2011-mens-running-shoes-on-sale-white-black-varsity-red" >nike air max 2011 mens running shoes on sale white black varsity red</a> [url=http://www.spiritedveg.com/brand-new/nike-air-max-2011-mens-running-shoes-on-sale-white-black-varsity-red]nike air max 2011 mens running shoes on sale white black varsity red[/url]

24 Oct 2018 - 21:20 BST


<a href="http://www.kumpiapartement.com/current-release/hot-sale-discount-50%25-under-armour-boy-youth-curry-i-one-1-ua-black-silver-charcoal-grey">hot sale discount 50% under armour boy youth curry i one 1 ua black silver charcoal grey</a><a href="http://www.kumpiapartement.com/cyber_monday_sale/puma-by-miharayasuhiro-my-54">puma by miharayasuhiro my 54</a><a href="http://www.kumpiapartement.com/editors-pick/nike-air-max-270-boys-preschool">nike air max 270 boys preschool</a><a href="http://www.kumpiapartement.com/featured/first-look-at-the-nike-kyrie-1-australia">first look at the nike kyrie 1 australia</a> <a href="http://www.groupearmoa.com/recommended/asics-gt-ii-navyred-3" >asics gt ii navyred 3</a> [url=http://www.groupearmoa.com/recommended/asics-gt-ii-navyred-3]asics gt ii navyred 3[/url]

26 Oct 2018 - 22:13 BST


<a href="http://www.power-of-thoughts.com/on sale/womens-air-jordan-13-hyper-pink-black-ivory-pink">womens air jordan 13 hyper pink black ivory pink</a><a href="http://www.power-of-thoughts.com/online-sale/men-nike-11-on-behalf-of-bryant-black-purple-yellow">men nike 11 on behalf of bryant black purple yellow</a><a href="http://www.power-of-thoughts.com/online-shop/nike-air-max-97-ultra-17-gym-redspeed-red-black-latest">nike air max 97 ultra 17 gym redspeed red black latest</a><a href="http://www.power-of-thoughts.com/online/black-white-paramount-blue-nike-magista-obra-ii-ag-pro-football-shoes">black white paramount blue nike magista obra ii ag pro football shoes</a> <a href="http://www.cgcre.com/replica/adidas-sneakers-pw-tennis-hu" >adidas sneakers pw tennis hu</a> [url=http://www.cgcre.com/replica/adidas-sneakers-pw-tennis-hu]adidas sneakers pw tennis hu[/url]

29 Oct 2018 - 22:29 GMT


<a href="http://www.cinnamoninsole.com/brands/air-jordan-9-ix-fusion-icy-girls-white-liquid-lime">air jordan 9 ix fusion icy girls white liquid lime</a><a href="http://www.cinnamoninsole.com/cheap-store/nike-air-foamposite-pro-redblack-blue">nike air foamposite pro redblack blue</a><a href="http://www.cinnamoninsole.com/collection/adidas-eqt-running-support-93-berlin-marathon">adidas eqt running support 93 berlin marathon</a><a href="http://www.cinnamoninsole.com/complete-size/nike-air-max-2014-night-factor-black-atomic-orange-volt-621077">nike air max 2014 night factor black atomic orange volt 621077</a> <a href="http://www.versicherungs-mafia.com/online-sale/custom-kicks-grand-finale-lebron-8-package-by-mizzee-customs" >custom kicks grand finale lebron 8 package by mizzee customs</a> [url=http://www.versicherungs-mafia.com/online-sale/custom-kicks-grand-finale-lebron-8-package-by-mizzee-customs]custom kicks grand finale lebron 8 package by mizzee customs[/url]

03 Nov 2018 - 18:18 GMT


<a href="http://www.shortsalesb.com/discount-price/nike-air-max-90-jcrd-wolf-grey">nike air max 90 jcrd wolf grey</a><a href="http://www.shortsalesb.com/discount/womens-nike-free-tr-fit-5-training-shoes-melon-gray">womens nike free tr fit 5 training shoes melon gray</a><a href="http://www.shortsalesb.com/factory-price/nike-air-jordan-1-flight-5-premium">nike air jordan 1 flight 5 premium</a><a href="http://www.shortsalesb.com/factory-sale/nike-air-max-97-summit-white-aq8760-100">nike air max 97 summit white aq8760 100</a> <a href="http://www.2majesticmortuary.com/2018/nike-air-max-95-jd-sports-black-game-royal" >nike air max 95 jd sports black game royal</a> [url=http://www.2majesticmortuary.com/2018/nike-air-max-95-jd-sports-black-game-royal]nike air max 95 jd sports black game royal[/url]

12 Nov 2018 - 06:24 GMT


<a href="http://www.onelife2liv.com/current-release/2019-copuon-air-jordan-13-gs-grape">2019 copuon air jordan 13 gs grape</a><a href="http://www.onelife2liv.com/cyber_monday_sale/cheap-nike-air-presto-escape-brown-white-wheat-yellow-blue-shoes-for-sale">cheap nike air presto escape brown white wheat yellow blue shoes for sale</a><a href="http://www.onelife2liv.com/editors-pick/159722c-426-converse-one-star-pinstripe-low-top-mens-shoe-navy">159722c 426 converse one star pinstripe low top mens shoe navy</a><a href="http://www.onelife2liv.com/featured/wiedenkennedy">wiedenkennedy</a> <a href="http://www.graceevangelicalchurchabudhabi.com/Just-released/air-jordan-10-retro-white-varsity-red-free-shipping" >air jordan 10 retro white varsity red free shipping</a> [url=http://www.graceevangelicalchurchabudhabi.com/Just-released/air-jordan-10-retro-white-varsity-red-free-shipping]air jordan 10 retro white varsity red free shipping[/url]

14 Nov 2018 - 12:12 GMT


<a href="http://www.elizabethaustinassociates.com/buty/amazon-it-nike-air-max-bianche">amazon it nike air max bianche</a><a href="http://www.elizabethaustinassociates.com/chaussures/chaussures-baskets-nike-air-max-90-femme-just-do-it-pas-cher">chaussures baskets nike air max 90 femme just do it pas cher</a><a href="http://www.elizabethaustinassociates.com/dam/zapatillas-nike-air-huarache-run-ultra-negro-hombre">zapatillas nike air huarache run ultra negro hombre</a><a href="http://www.elizabethaustinassociates.com/dame/nike-air-max-2017-rouge-pas-cher">nike air max 2017 rouge pas cher</a> <a href="http://www.farrellsportsconcepts.com/replica/adidas-obyo-forum-mid-db-x-david-beckham-beige-black" >adidas obyo forum mid db x david beckham beige black</a> [url=http://www.farrellsportsconcepts.com/replica/adidas-obyo-forum-mid-db-x-david-beckham-beige-black]adidas obyo forum mid db x david beckham beige black[/url]

19 Nov 2018 - 13:29 GMT


<a href="http://www.ilovesgcondo.com/category/adidas-messi-15.4-in-mens-football-boots-shoes-soccer-cleats-us-11-yellow-black-b32902">adidas messi 15.4 in mens football boots shoes soccer cleats us 11 yellow black b32902</a><a href="http://www.ilovesgcondo.com/cheap-store/image-air-jordan-1-banned-with-nike-on-the-tongue-image-4">image air jordan 1 banned with nike on the tongue image 4</a><a href="http://www.ilovesgcondo.com/classic_trainers/nike-kyrie-3-camo-pe-yellow-maroon">nike kyrie 3 camo pe yellow maroon</a><a href="http://www.ilovesgcondo.com/clearance/nike-air-max-90-essential-men-leather-mesh-black-trainers">nike air max 90 essential men leather mesh black trainers</a> <a href="http://www.westernmasscatholichomeschoolers.com/black_friday_sale/womens-nike-air-max-90-ultra-essential-blue-legend-hot-lava-sunset-glow-blue-legend-724981-400-casual-shoes" >womens nike air max 90 ultra essential blue legend hot lava sunset glow blue legend 724981 400 casual shoes</a> [url=http://www.westernmasscatholichomeschoolers.com/black_friday_sale/womens-nike-air-max-90-ultra-essential-blue-legend-hot-lava-sunset-glow-blue-legend-724981-400-casual-shoes]womens nike air max 90 ultra essential blue legend hot lava sunset glow blue legend 724981 400 casual shoes[/url]

30 Nov 2018 - 06:37 GMT

Add your comment…